• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • LOG IN
  • SUPPORT
  • CART
  • ABOUT
  • MEDIA
  • HOST LAUREL
  • CONTACT
  • BLOG
LAUREL BEVERSDORF

LAUREL BEVERSDORF

Movement Courses and Teacher Training

  • ONLINE COURSES
  • LIVE/ONLINE EVENTS
  • PRIVATE SESSIONS
  • VIRTUAL STUDIO
  • Nav Social Menu

    • Facebook
    • Instagram

Pigeon Pose and Tight Hips—A Remake of a Classic Tale

Leave a Comment

For every time I get a question about shoulder pain in chaturanga, I get two for what students describe as “tight hips.” “How can I stretch my hip flexors?” they ask, pointing to the front of their pelvis.

In essence, they are asking for a recommended hip opener. But, what are hip openers?

Most of the time, when people think of the hip-opening asanas, they tend to think of asanas that don’t stretch the front of their hips, like the image above does, but rather asanas that involve a position of external rotation and flexion of the hips. Also, they don’t imagine active/dynamic stretching like the example above, but more passive, static stretches. You know them as well as I do—postures like baddha konasana, thread the needle/figure four, or pigeon (single or double, take your pick!) that have been given all sorts of magical powers in yogaland.

The truth is, any pose or movement that asks your hips to move beyond what is your “normal” range of motion, has the potential to feel like a stretch and could constitute a “hip opener.”

Meaning, it might cause you to feel your hip tightness. And, if you do the stretch enough, it can lead to you having a larger “normal” range of motion.

Side note: an interesting feature of pigeon pose, pictured above, in terms of its joint positions is that it is a pose that stretches both the lateral hip compartment (of the front hip), but also the hip flexor muscles (of the back hip.) These are both areas students often report feeling “tight” but when we think of hip openers, we’re often thinking of poses that explore positions like that of the front hip in pigeon.

I myself spent a ton of time in pigeon pose when my own hips felt “tight.” I also had the idea that by opening my hips I’d somehow be happier, unplagued by stressful emotions, and a better person. Having tight hips meant something was wrong with me, and gosh darn it I was going to fix that.

Spoiler alert: pigeon pose didn’t help me feel happier or less plagued by stressful emotions. It didn’t make me a better person. In fact, as the years went on, the more I did pigeon, the less of any of those things I felt. In fact, I felt more stress and more pain.

Around 6 years into my yoga teaching career, I also started to hear from a lot of senior yoga teachers coming out about hip pain that they’d kept secret for years. Many ultimately required hip replacements. I laid in bed at night wondering when I’d have to schedule my surgery, since I was convinced that I had the same problem they did.

After that freak-out, I went through a phase where I demonized all passive stretching and stopped practicing and teaching it. I believed that passive stretching overstretched ligaments and caused my joints, like my SI joints, to dislocate or slip out of place.

However, after learning more about pain, as well as the difference between flexibility (total joint range of motion) versus mobility (the joint range of motion our nervous system can actively control) I settled on what I think is a more nuanced understanding of the role passive stretching played in my hip pain.

You see, the perception of tightness I had might have been a message from my nervous system, not the outcome of too much irresponsible passive stretching.

Ligaments and joints, like the SI joint, are incredibly tough, and they get tougher through tensile load (stretching them!) so it doesn’t make sense that a relatively low tensile load, like a passive stretch, would be enough to overwhelm them.

In actuality, the tight feeling I experienced was a way of limiting my range of motion in a stretch, in essence saying, “Hey there, not so fast, you’re not going to move that way. It’s not safe.” Sensing a lack of control in my joints (mobility, which involves being strong in end range positions), my body was tensing up.

The way to calm it down wasn’t to passively stretch more. It wasn’t to plop down in pigeon and hope for the best.

I had to improve my hip joint strength and control to enforce a feeling of safety in my joints that would allow the joints to expand their range of motion—i.e., “open” them. Hence I began my journey of exploring loaded movements—the kind with weights and bands and other fun things that expanded the vocabulary of how my hips (and my whole body) could feel beyond “tight” and “open.” 

Now, when a student asks me for help with “tight hips” and wants some passive stretches, I don’t automatically start ringing alarm bells and tell them to “abort!” like I once did. Instead, I encourage them to do the poses that feel good, while also asking them to consider adding in more active mobility and strengthening work (which their yoga practice and daily life probably wasn’t giving them enough of.)

In short, we don’t need to demonize pigeon pose (or any other asana, for that matter) when we reconcile the limitations of the postures with our need for more strength, variable loading, and pain science.

Rather, getting creative with our yoga will do the body lots of good—adding strength, adaptability, mobility, and a healthy dose of fun.

Here’s a video I made in partnership with Yoga Journal for my course Resistance Bands 101. In it, I share a banded version of Eka Pada Apanasana with a looped resistance band. The purpose of this banded pose is to actively target strengthening (rather than passively stretching) the hip flexor muscles. Give it a try!

 

Filed Under: Body of Knowledge, English

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

  • Topics

Footer

Join me on Instagram

laurelbeversdorf

Prepare to Pull Up Mini Course Testimonial Time! 👇#repost @wholecore It took 5 MONTHS of training to get my chin above the bar. Is my pull-up picture perfect?  No way! I need a lot more practice to do it gracefully but this milestone feels like a big accomplishment.Last fall I wasn’t even close to doing an unassisted pull up. Then I joined the Prepare to Pull Up program with my #rollmodelmethod teacher @laurelbeversdorf.For 2 months I worked on WHOLE BODY strength exercises designed to prepare my body to do pull-ups.  I worked HARD 2-3 times a week for 12 weeks. I was *so close* but my practice plateaued so I took a break for 6 weeks and started focusing on other exercises. During that time I only attempted 1pull-up once a week. Lo and behold when I went back to training pull-ups I felt a lot stronger and just a couple of weeks later - BINGO! The moral of the story - there is no easy or quick way to do a pull-up or any other strength movement for that matter. It takes consistency, patience, perseverance, guidance and sometimes you just need to take a break.#mondaymotivation💪#wholecore #strongmamas #fitafter50 #fitafter40 #perimenopausefitness
In this week’s episode on the Movement Logic Pod In this week’s episode on the Movement Logic Podcast, I had the pleasure to talk to nutrition scientist, Dr. Ben House, PhD. @drbenhouseDr. House has been working in nutrition and fitness for over 15 years, and has published many articles in peer reviewed, scientific journals.In our conversation, we talk about the intersection between nutrition and fitness, specifically for women between the ages of 40-65 who may exercise and eat with a number of related (but different) goals like performance, health, longevity, and aesthetics.You will learn:Why food fear spreads like wildfire on the internetThat muscle can prevent hyperglycemia and inflammation.How the energy from food (listed on food labels) does not correspond with how your body metabolizes and gets energy from that food.That low carb diets, like keto go back to the mid 1800s and then resurge every couple of decades.That body-building is not just about aesthetics.Why thinner is not automatically healthier and what the “cost of leanness” is.How fat is responsible for the evolutionary success of humans.What sarcopenic obesity is.What apophenia is and how it is responsible for lots of myths about weight gain and menopause.Why 8,000 steps/day and the CDC’s physical activity guidelines will move the needle a lot further than Andrew Huberman’s litany of “protocols”.Ben’s research-supported recommendations for daily dietary intake.What body recomposition is and how it could help people maintain weight loss.LINK IN BIO TO LISTEN 👀Or search Movement Logic: Strong Opinions Loosely Held wherever you get your podcasts. 👨‍🎤👩🏻‍🎤Don’t forget to SU B S C R I B E 💫
It may not seem obvious, but your abdominals play It may not seem obvious, but your abdominals play a very important role in pull ups.So while everyone is out there trying to get abs, you could be out there trying to get pulls ups—working on multiple ways of being strong all at once. You might accidentally get the strongest abdominal muscles of your life.That’s my favorite way to train.Instead of trying to change your body (which women are constantly told they need to do) try to change WHAT YOU CAN DO WITH IT.Have a strength goal. Work toward it consistently. Notice a whole bunch of fringe benefits!Today is day 2 of the Prepare to Pull Up free mini course and you can still join and get all five mini-workouts.Link in bio 👀
It’s DAY 1 of the #preparetopullup FREE mini-cou It’s DAY 1 of the #preparetopullup FREE mini-course!Today students received a pull up warm up with 5 exercises to warm up for pull up practice. One of the exercises was “the dead hang”.Here guest teacher Eli and I share 7️⃣ different ways to bring the dead hang to life!These are wonderful ways to input some excellent, novel loads to your hands, shoulders & spine.Enjoy hanging around with us today! 😉And it’s not too late to join! Link in bio 👀
Giving the phrase “hanging out” in the poses n Giving the phrase “hanging out” in the poses new meaning. 😏😁Tomorrow the Prepare to Pull Up free mini course begins.Participants receive 5 mini pull up specific workouts, one of which includes the exercise Active Hang Knees to Chest (which looks an awful lot like chair pose!)In the spirit of asana-themed pull up bar moves, the exercise would be like “hanging out” in the transition from mountain pose (tadasana) to chair pose (utkatasana).We’ll do this exercise in a quickie 6-min core workout. There may be some planking, too. 😉Buuut, today for my post, I thought I’d riff on the idea that hanging around could invoke some other familiar shapes.If you have a relatively low pull up bar there’s lots of possibilities for playing with the asanas.Feel how, from the perspective of hanging, familiar poses have new stuff to offer your experience than you may not have felt before.And psssst! It’s not too late to join the  Prepare to Pull Up Free Mini Course! We start tomorrow!Link in bio 👀
The Prepare to Pull Up Free Mini Course starts tom The Prepare to Pull Up Free Mini Course starts tomorrow 5/31/23.Get 5 days of quick pull up workouts and exercises. Strengthen your grip, shoulders, core, and even lower body. (This is a whole body, beginner-friendly workout!)Link in bio 👀
When people have had pain in their bodies for a lo When people have had pain in their bodies for a long time, and have tried every solution under the sun, it can be hard to believe that something as simple as movement will get them out of pain. As movement teachers, we know this to be true, and it’s vital that we possess the skills necessary to help our students and clients experience this for themselves.
Need some guidance on how to do that? Right now, we’re offering a site wide sale on ALL of our tutorials!!Every Movement Logic Tutorial contains hours of anatomy, kinesiology, myth-busting, and most importantly, dozens of exercises that will help you train strength, flexibility, and functional movement, for whatever you or your clients want to do in life.And, the more you invest, the more you save, with up to 35% off our popular tutorials.
Sale ends TONIGHT at midnight, so don’t delay. Click on the link in bio to learn more and to save!
😩Feeling stuck in your teaching? 😩😩Bored 😩Feeling stuck in your teaching?
😩😩Bored of the sound of your own voice? 😩😩😩Want to feel inspired, but not sure where to go for help? We’ve been there.
Here’s the good news: we can help you.
💥💥💥Right now, we’re offering a site wide sale on ALL of our tutorials!!💥💥💥Every Movement Logic Tutorial contains hours of anatomy, kinesiology, myth-busting, and most importantly, dozens of exercises that will help you train strength, flexibility, and functional movement, for whatever you or your clients want to do in life.And, the more you invest, the more you save, with up to 35% off our popular tutorials.
Sale ends Monday May 29th at midnight, so don’t delay.🔗🔗🔗Click on the link in bio to learn more and to save!
😩😩😩That feeling when you have taken a ton 😩😩😩That feeling when you have taken a ton of trainings on anatomy and kinesiology but still don’t know how to integrate any of it into your classes.
Well, guess what? We’ve done the heavy lifting for you. Right now, we’re offering a site wide sale on ALL of our tutorials!!Every Movement Logic Tutorial contains hours of anatomy, kinesiology, myth-busting, and most importantly, dozens of exercises that will help you train strength, flexibility, and functional movement, for whatever you or your clients want to do in life.And, the more you invest, the more you save, with up to 35% off our popular tutorials.
Sale ends Monday May 20th at midnight, so don’t delay. Click on the link in bio to learn more and to save!
What does inclusivity as a movement teacher look l What does inclusivity as a movement teacher look like? For one, it’s seeing the people in front of you and helping them to help themselves feel better in their bodies.
Need more ideas on how to do that? You’re in luck! We’re offering a site wide sale on ALL of our tutorials!!Every Movement Logic Tutorial contains hours of anatomy, kinesiology, myth-busting, and most importantly, dozens of exercises that will help you train strength, flexibility, and functional movement, for whatever you or your clients want to do in life.And, the more you invest, the more you save, with up to 35% off our popular tutorials.
Sale ends Monday May 29th at midnight, so don’t delay. Click on the link in bio to learn more and to save!
🤔If the only thing you know to offer your clien 🤔If the only thing you know to offer your clients and students with pelvic floor pain or continence issues is more cowbell – err – more Kegels, we can help.✅The @movementlogictutorials Pelvic Floor Tutorial is jam packed with dozens and dozens of exercises that consider the many and varied reasons why someone might need help with their pelvic floor outside of the standard issue “do more Kegels” response.
✅✅Even more good news: right now, we’re offering a site wide sale on ALL of our tutorials!!✅✅✅Every Movement Logic Tutorial contains hours of anatomy, kinesiology, myth-busting, and most importantly, dozens of exercises that will help you train strength, flexibility, and functional movement, for whatever you or your clients want to do in life.✅✅✅✅And, the more you invest, the more you save, with up to 35% off our popular tutorials.
➡️Sale ends Monday May 29th at midnight, so don’t delay.🔗Click on the link in bio to learn more and to save!
In 2017, @sarahcourtdpt and I noticed a problem in In 2017, @sarahcourtdpt and I noticed a problem in the kind of continuing education available for movement teachers. There was plenty of content to go around - but not much functional, useful, and applicable movement education that people could actually use immediately with their clients (aka Too Much Fluff, Not Enough Substance).So along with @trinaaltman, we set out to do things differently by creating @movementlogictutorials.6 years, 6 tutorials, and 2 additional collaborators later (@anulamaiberg and @yogawalla), we’re pretty proud of what we’ve created.To celebrate, we’re offering a site wide sale on ALL of our tutorials!!Every Movement Logic Tutorial contains hours of anatomy, kinesiology, myth-busting, and most importantly, dozens of exercises that will help you train strength, flexibility, and functional movement, for whatever you or your clients want to do in life.And, the more you invest, the more you save, with up to 35% off our popular tutorials.
Sale ends Monday May 29th at midnight, so don’t delay. Click on the link in bio to learn more and to save! 👀🔗
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Quick Links

  • MEMBERSHIP STUDIO
  • LEARN IN PERSON
  • LEARN ONLINE
  • HOST LAUREL
  • CONTACT
  • BLOG

Start Learning

LEARN MORE

Copyright © 2023 Laurel Beversdorf · Design by GreatOakCircle.com
Privacy Notice - Australia | Privacy Notice - California | Privacy Notice - EU | Privacy Notice | Terms of use | Cancellation Policy

Tired of status quo instruction and ready to move beyond the script?
_____________
Enter your name + email below to join the resistance...errr my list...and get 3 FREE sequences to strengthen and soothe your neck and shoulders using resistance bands, a kettlebell, and therapy balls.
YOUR NAME:
YOUR EMAIL: